USPS’s environmental impact statement seems designed to justify its timid electrification strategy

Electrifying the US Postal Service fleet would be one of the most effective ways for the federal government to encourage EV adoption (while saving taxpayers billions of dollars and eliminating tons of emissions). However, there is a strong faction at the agency that seems determined to prevent that from happening, and some see the draft environmental impact statement (EIS) that the agency released last week as the latest salvo from the “save the gas vehicles” contingent.

In February, the USPS decided to award a $6-billion contract to Oshkosh Defense to build a new delivery vehicle to replace the agency’s sadly outdated fleet. Under the current proposal, only 10% of these will be electric, and the new EIS seems designed to support this plan.

The Zero Emission Transportation Association (ZETA) says the EIS “demonstrates a clear, illogical commitment to ICE vehicles over battery-electric vehicles, which hinges on outdated and incorrect information.”

The EIS looks at only two alternative scenarios for the new fleet: 90% ICE vehicles and 10% EVs; or 100% EVs. The USPS does not consider the 75% EV fleet composition proposed in the Postal Vehicle Modernization Act (HR1636), sponsored by US Representative Jared Huffman.

The EIS report acknowledges that a 100% EV fleet would produce 200% less emissions than the 90% ICE/10% EV option, but calls electrification financially infeasible considering the current financial status of the USPS. According to ZETA, this analysis is inaccurate for several reasons: “The cost calculation inexplicably uses nickel manganese batteries, which are more expensive—and less common and efficient—than EV industry-standard lithium-ion batteries. Furthermore, the USPS’s conclusions about BEVs’ financial impact did not consider its own analysis about the social cost of carbon: The USPS calculated that the 100% BEV scenario could save three times as much in social costs compared to the 90% ICE and 10% BEV scenario. The EIS also cites the cost of charging infrastructure as a barrier to the 100% BEV scenario, but it does not list the assumptions or calculations used to make that conclusion.”

A recent report from the Electrification Coalition and Atlas Public Policy found that “USPS offers a uniquely strong case for vehicle electrification.” According to the study, “Federal Fleet Electrification Assessment,” by 2025, EVs will be less expensive than conventional vehicles for more than 99 percent of the USPS light-duty fleet, and electrification could save taxpayers some $2.9 billion. By 2030, that figure increases to nearly 100 percent, and the switch could save $4.6 billion.

The USPS also concluded that EVs are incapable of handling the distance, weather conditions, or charging requirements on up to 12,500 of the agency’s 232,000 routes. As ZETA point out, the supposedly EV-unfriendly routes represent less than 5.4% of the USPS’s total routes. Furthermore, the USPS does not plan to replace 100% of its existing fleet—rather, it is replacing 22.9% to 75.6% of its fleet over the next ten years.

“Its remaining vehicles could easily cover these routes, or the USPS could purchase a small percentage of new, fuel-efficient ICE vehicles to cover these routes,” writes ZETA. “The USPS inexplicably argues that because 5.4% of its routes are not a good fit for electrification, it is justified in acquiring a 90% gas-powered new fleet.”

“The USPS cherry-picked their models and data in order to weave the narrative they needed to justify their decision to pursue [a mostly ICE fleet],” ZETA concludes. “The USPS’s EIS shows a clear bias against BEVs by excluding data, relying on unrealistic assumptions, and mistaking simple facts.”

ZETA plans to participate in the formal public comment period of the draft EIS.

Source: Zero Emission Transportation Association

Create Account. Already Registered? Log In

EV Engineering Webinars

The free webinar sessions from our Fall Virtual Conference are now available to view on-demand. Register for a session below to watch the recording and download the presentation.