EV Engineering News

New papers cast doubt on lithium-air breakthrough


Back in October, Cambridge scientists wowed the battery world with an announcement that they had demonstrated a highly efficient and long-lasting lithium-oxygen battery. Lithium-oxygen, or lithium-air, batteries have a theoretical energy density ten times that of lithium-ion solutions, but suffer from poor cycle life.

In a paper published in the journal Science, Tao Liu and colleagues claimed to have overcome this obstacle by using a porous graphene electrode and by using lithium iodide and water as mediators.

Alas, several researchers from universities and national labs in the US, China, and Australia have now disputed the Cambridge team’s findings in two separate dissents, saying that the original results could not be replicated. The dissenters found that lithium iodide does not perform the function that the earlier paper claimed.

“Based on a simple thermodynamic analysis, we show that iodide-mediated electrochemical decomposition of lithium hydroxide (LiOH) likely occurs through a different mechanism than that proposed by Liu et al,” writes Carnegie Mellon Professor Venkatasubramanian Viswanathan in one of the dissenting papers. “It is therefore possible that the system described in Liu et al may not form the basis for a rechargeable lithium-oxygen battery.”

Another paper, from a team led by Yue Shen, reports similar findings: “We argue that LiOH cannot be oxidized by triiodide. The charge capacity is from the oxidation of I- instead of LiOH. The limited-capacity cycling test is misleading when the electrolyte contributes considerable parasitic reaction capacity.”

“The breakthrough is not a breakthrough, and we are in a sense no further along in lithium-air than we were,” Viswanathan told Quartz.


Source: Quartz

Create Account. Already Registered? Log In

Virtual Conference on EV Infrastructure: Free to Attend

Don't miss our next Virtual Conference on December 4-6, 2023. Register for the free webinar sessions below and reserve your spot to watch them live or on-demand.


EV Engineering Webinars & Whitepapers

EV Tech Explained

The Tech

Elevate the efficiency of EV battery systems with electronic components (Whitepaper)

Renault and Valeo develop new electric motor for EVs 

Asahi Kasei to expand coating capacity for lithium-ion battery separators

Fluor wins engineering contract for industrial-scale sodium-ion battery plant

The Vehicles & Infrastructure

EPRI’s new groundbreaking grid planning tool for electric transportation (Webinar)

Circontrol’s next-generation Raption EV chargers feature 240 kW of power, new user-friendly features

Rental companies account for a third of fossil cars sold in Norway

U.S. Steel pilots battery-electric locomotives

TeraWatt Infrastructure breaks ground on heavy-duty EV charging site near Port of Long Beach

Utah DOT receives $43 million in grants to build EV fast charging stations

SSE Energy Solutions to build electric truck charging hub in Birmingham, UK

Tips for fleet managers transitioning from diesel to EVs (Webinar)

KEBA and Easelink work to develop automated hands-free conductive charging for EVs at home

Clenergy EV adds more CPOs to its European e-roaming network, enables touch-free payments